The core brand value is "Prestige."
The logo should be a medal (think olympic gold medal) or an award statue (think Oscar) with some connection to the game Rocket League. For instance the gold from Rio this year with a car from the game (http://bit.ly/2ddzroh, or as in the game's logo here: http://bit.ly/2dArKdZ) in place of the olympic logo.
Logo should also include the name, "The Rocket Dailies". IT DOES NOT NEED TO BE ON THE MEDAL THOUGH. In fact, I think I'd prefer them be separated, with a fairly clean medal with the text right next to it.
Main design inspiration should be the Oscars (or other award shows) and luxury car brands like Lexus or Maserati. I'm thinking rich and sturdy, with subtle yet intricate details. Shiny, but not overwhelmingly so. More like gleaming or glimmering. Dark background with gold or white for the logo and name.
A successful logo will make players of the game see it and say, "I want to be able to show off that I won that." It shouldn't be cute or at all cheap, flimsy, or insubstantial looking. It should be mature, powerful, and elegant.
The website is already designed and operational, and I'm fairly happy with everything but the logo, so it can serve as inspiration too. It's http://therocketdailies.com. Please do not be too influenced by the current logo though, there's a reason why we're here.
Here are some more random images for inspiration, in case that helps: